Bright Simons
1. Ghana’s mines minister says he has asked Cabinet to amend the lease granted to the owners of Ghana’s first lithium mine, Ewoyaa.
2. Last year, there was an uproar as many Ghanaians felt that the original deal was bad for Ghana. The country will get 10% royalty (i.e. share of gross sales) and 13% shareholding (equity) in the mining project.
3. Reportedly, the lithium company, Atlantic, wants the terms for the mine changed to 5% royalty (i.e. halved from 10%). They also want corporate tax slashed and levies removed or trimmed drastically.
4. One would have thought that given the uproar last year, the government would see it wise to open broad consultations. If 10% royalty plus standard taxes were called “colonial” then, surely 5% royalty and low taxes would be called, what, “economic treason”?
5. The whole affair doesn’t seem to make any sense. Let me explain my confusion.
6. Atlantic says that the fall in lithium prices has forced it to stop exploration and pause operations this year. This can not be correct because I went to the mining area last year and was told by the inhabitants that the company hasn’t been active for more than a year. See here: https://brightsimons.com/2024/12/the-dusty-roads-to-ghanas-first-lithium-mine/
. The company’s issues thus predate the price falls. It is true that investor return (IRR) has plunged from 94% to ~14%, but the return was always outsized.
7. The company’s issues likely include delays in getting its main funding partner, Piedmont, to commit to financing disbursements and, also, convincing offtakers to sign forward contracts. Without these funds, it has simply become cash-strapped.
8. The price-fall argument is suspect. When this govt came to office, spodumene concentrate (5/6%), what the mine will be producing, was selling at $815. As usual, it kept fluctuating. Throughout Q1 2025, Atlantic was lobbying massively for its mining lease to be ratified by Parliament so it can start mining.
9. Spodumene is now at $711. The price is actually up from $617 q month ago. The forecast is for it to avg about $850 in coming quarters. In short, nothing much has changed in the pricing picture from the beginning of the year when the government promised to fast-track approvals.
10. WHAT THEN IS DRIVING THE SUDDEN PUSH TO LOWER THE COUNTRY’S SHARE OF THE LITHIUM FIND? Where are the people that just a few days ago were talking about Ghana owning and controlling its mineral resources?
11. When the mining lease was sent to Parliament in July 2024 for ratification so that mining could begin pronto, the spodumene price was in the $900 range. From the middle of August to October 2024, the price hovered mostly within the $740 and $780 range.
12. THROUGHOUT THIS PERIOD, THERE WAS INTENSE LOBBYING BY CHIEFS AND OTHERS FOR THE LEASE TO BE RATIFIED BY PARLIAMENT. Essentially NOTHING has changed in pricing terms between August 2024 & July 2025. So, had Parliament heeded the lobbying and approved the lease in, say, November 2024 (like on 8th Nov 2024 when spodumene was $771), the mine would still not have been built.
13. The story about prices doesn’t add up. The govt should tell us the REAL STORY why it wants to go down this path. And the advice sent by the Minister should be published for broad public debate. This whole mess has also elevated the issue of refining. Whilst spodumene prices are set to remain subdued for years due to the Chinese pushing new ores, lithium hydroxide, a refined lithium salt, has disconnected from raw spodumene prices and is set to see a 102% increase in prices by 2028 according to Goldman Sachs.
14. Whilst at it, the government should also release the Green Mining/Minerals Policy the previous government said had been prepared and share a draft of the green minerals law that was reported to be in the works.
15. Let us see all those who have been talking about local ownership and whatnots in recent days and weeks show that they really meant all that stuff, and it wasn’t just because their favourite people were involved.
